Recent Reviews
The Cap'ns Slice
Alyssa Smith : 5 on 6/22/2024 11:30 pm
Found this shop out of pure luck while on a road trip and not to be dramatic but it was the best slice of pizza I’ve ever had. The level of perfection that crust was cooked to was unreal. Husband and I both agreed we will be stopping again on the way back. Insanely recommended!!
Alyssa Smith
1719099046
5
5
The Cap'ns Slice
Zach Goodman : 3 on 10/19/2024 8:03 pm
So, solid 3 stars. Best texture I've had since leaving New York. Dough is imported from New York so that makes sense. Flavor on the other hand, is sorely lacking. The dough tastes like it either never had salt or is over proofed. I got the James t Kirk. I'm not sure they added any spices to the sauce, may just be tomatoes. Certainly all the ingredients are top notch, Don't get me wrong, it tastes good, but it's certainly not NYC level pizza. it lacks depth and complexity, the flavors are all on the front end and don't have any follow through.
Zach Goodman
1729368198
3
5
The Cap'ns Slice
Allison Blakeman : 5 on 1/24/2024 1:39 am
We love this place. Their usual offerings are so so good and their special pizzas are always tasty, too. Their pesto and vodka sauces are my absolute favorite. It’s so nice being able to stop in and just pick up a couple of slices if we don’t feel like getting a whole pizza. Plus you get to try all the different kinds!
Allison Blakeman
1706060397
5
5
The Cap'ns Slice
Modal title